When a documentary leaves the answer open

· · Worked example and worksheet

After a screening of Three Identical Strangers, someone asks what the researchers finally concluded. The discussion leader remembers that the brothers received thousands of pages of records. Is that an answer? Before writing the screening notes, separate what was handed over from what the recipients could learn from it.

1. Keep the audience’s question

Write “What conclusion did the study reach?” at the top of the page. In the margin, write the narrower question you can check: “What did the filmmaker and a participant say they found in the files they discussed?” Keeping both questions prevents an account of getting access from turning into a claim about a scientific result. This example discusses the ending.

2. Read two accounts of the same files

In an interview with director Tim Wardle, the interviewer asks what came of the access mentioned at the end. Wardle describes about 11,000 heavily redacted pages received by the brothers and his producer. He describes detail in those pages and says they gave him no concrete finding. Keep “about” with the number and Wardle’s name with the account.

Participant Bobby Shafran, speaking to the Los Angeles Times in 2018, questioned what the observations had yielded and said the results had never been published. This records what a participant understood at that point. Two interviews can give you two perspectives on one release of records. Counting the interviews as two independent investigations would overstate your evidence.

3. Write the note for the next viewer

In interviews about the film, Wardle described access to a large set of redacted records, and Shafran questioned what the research had established. Neither interview identifies a final study result. What the researchers ultimately concluded is still open in these screening notes.

Compare that paragraph with “The researchers found nothing.” The shorter sentence assigns a result to the researchers. Our two speakers describe the records available to them. Use the screening-note worksheet to keep the question, the speaker, the evidence and the limit in the same row. The blank row is for another film.

4. Decide what could change the answer

A final report with identifiable authors, a date, methods and findings could change the note. Another interview repeating the number of pages would help trace the story of access but would leave the main question open. Date a revision and identify the evidence that changed your wording. There is no need to ask participants to disclose private files for a film-club discussion.

If the disagreement is about who supplied the words in a subtitle, use the documentary quotation ledger. For the next discussion, try checking what an audience figure can establish before describing a film’s effect.


Contact us at: [email protected]
www.SpeakUpProductionsCo.com
www.JohnChoura.com
| www.MarketingSTL.com Give a Damn? Home Give a Damn? Team Give a Damn? Proposal Give a Damn? Media Get Involved with Give a Damn? Give a Damn? Goods
Give a Damn? Home About Give a Damn? Documentary Give a Damn? Team Give a Damn? Proposal Give a Damn? Media Give a Damn? Goods
Analytics privacy
Microsoft Clarity / Privacy